Home
/
Bills
/

C-228

BILLDEFEATED
Private Member's Bill

45th Parliament · Session 1

Bill C-228: An Act to amend the Department of Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development Act (prior review of treaties by Parliament)

Introduced

September 18, 2025

Current Stage

BillDefeated

Last Updated

January 28, 2026

Sponsor

Mario Simard

Community Support

Community Vote

0% Support

0 votes

Politicians' Vote

9% Support

338 MPs

Support

Undecided/Abstain

Oppose

Cast Your Vote

Your vote helps inform others

Engagement

Votes

0

Comments

0

Follows

0

Parliamentary Votes

1

Statements

17

Bill C-228

Wed Jan 28 2026

An Act to amend the Department of Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development Act (prior review of treaties by Parliament)

Impact Rating

3/5

Short Summary

Stops the government from signing major international treaties without showing them to Parliament 21 days in advance for review.

Democracy
Parliamentary Oversight
International Trade
Foreign Policy
Treaties

This bill changes how Canada enters into international agreements. Currently, the Prime Minister and Cabinet can sign treaties (like trade deals or military alliances) without asking Parliament first. This bill would require the government to present any new treaty to the House of Commons at least 21 days before it is officially signed. For 'major' treaties—those involving taxes, trade, borders, or military sanctions—the government would be required to get advice (approval) from a Parliamentary committee before finalizing the deal.

Why does this bill exist?

Origin (Platform Promise)

This is a Private Member's Bill from the Bloc Québécois, likely driven by a desire for more regional and parliamentary control over federal foreign policy decisions.

  • Mandatory Waiting Period: The government must show the text of a treaty to Parliament at least 21 days before ratifying (finalizing) it.

  • Major Treaty Review: 'Major' treaties (involving trade, territory, taxes, or military sanctions) must be reviewed by a House of Commons committee.

  • Transparency: The government must publish an 'explanatory memorandum' explaining the deal's costs, obligations, and implications for Canada.

  • Emergency Loophole: The Cabinet can bypass this 21-day rule in 'exceptional circumstances' but must explain why to Parliament afterward.

  • Public Access: All treaties and changes must be published in the Canada Gazette and on a government website within specific timeframes.

Everyday Citizens

(Rights Expanded)

You will be able to read proposed international deals online before they become law.

Business Owners (Importers/Exporters)

(Harder)

Trade agreements may take longer to finalize, creating longer periods of uncertainty.

The Cabinet (Government Ministers)

(Harder)

Must prepare detailed reports and face committee questioning before signing international deals.

Provincial Impact

Provincial Impact

Low (Information Sharing) Interaction

Provinces do not get a direct vote, but the transparency allows provincial governments (like Quebec or Alberta) to see federal deals early and criticize them if they hurt provincial interests.

Benefits & Pros

Increases democratic oversight: MPs elected by the people get to see deals before they are permanent.

Prevents 'secret' deals: The public and media get to see the costs and obligations before Canada is locked in.

Ensures better vetting: Committees can catch mistakes or bad terms in trade agreements.

Beneficiaries

Members of Parliament (gain power)
Opposition Parties
The Public (more information)

Risks & Cons

Slows down diplomacy: Negotiating with other countries is harder if the Canadian government can't promise a quick signature.

Political gridlock: Opposition parties could use the 21-day period to block or delay necessary agreements for political points.

Reduced flexibility: In a global crisis, the government might need to act faster than this bill allows (though the emergency loophole exists).

Affected Groups

The Prime Minister/Cabinet (lose power)
Foreign Diplomats (slower negotiations)

Before & After

Currently, the Government negotiates a trade deal and signs it. Parliament only votes later on the laws needed to make it work. Under this bill, the Government negotiates the deal, but must pause for 21 days and let Parliament review it before signing.

Real World Scenario

Currently: The government signs a new free trade agreement with the UK. The next day, they tell the news. Under this Bill: The government finishes negotiations with the UK. They must table the text in Parliament. 21 days pass where MPs debate it. A committee issues a report. Only then can the Minister sign it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Votes on this bill

Vote 61

Negatived

2nd reading of Bill C-228, An Act to amend the Department of Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development Act (prior review of treaties by Parliament)

Wed Jan 28 2026

Yeas: 32

Nays: 302

Total: 338

Sponsor

Mario Simard

Member of Parliament

House of Commons

First reading

Completed on September 18, 2025

Second reading

Not yet started

Consideration in committee

Not yet started

Report stage

Not yet started

Third reading

Not yet started

Senate

First reading

Not yet started

Second reading

Not yet started

Third reading

Not yet started

Abuse Potential

The main abuse potential lies in the 'Exceptional Circumstances' clause (Section 12.4). A government wishing to avoid scrutiny could label every controversial treaty as an 'exceptional circumstance' to bypass the 21-day rule, effectively rendering the law useless. Conversely, opposition parties could abuse the review process to filibuster routine international agreements, damaging Canada's reputation as a reliable partner.

Implementation Risk

Low. The mechanisms for tabling documents in Parliament already exist. The only risk is political friction slowing down government business.

Broad Economic Impact

Indirect

Everyday Life

Minimal impact

Admin Burden

No changes to daily routine

Timeline

Immediate upon Royal Assent.