Home
/
Bills
/

C-231

HOUSEINCOMMITTEE
Private Member's Bill

45th Parliament · Session 1

Bill C-231: An Act to amend the Youth Criminal Justice Act

Introduced

September 19, 2025

Current Stage

HouseInCommittee

Last Updated

April 15, 2026

Sponsor

Luc Berthold

Community Support

Community Vote

0% Support

0 votes

Politicians' Vote

97% Support

337 MPs

Support

Undecided/Abstain

Oppose

Cast Your Vote

Your vote helps inform others

Engagement

Votes

0

Comments

0

Follows

0

Parliamentary Votes

1

Statements

3

Bill C-231

Wed Apr 15 2026

An Act to amend the Youth Criminal Justice Act

Impact Rating

3/5

Short Summary

Encourages addiction treatment for youth offenders by allowing delayed sentencing for rehab and preventing jail time solely for treatment failure.

Youth Justice
Addiction Treatment
Rehabilitation
Drugs
Mental Health

This bill amends the Youth Criminal Justice Act to prioritize rehabilitation over punishment for young people whose crimes are linked to drugs or alcohol. It requires police and judges to consider referring youth to addiction treatment programs instead of, or before, imposing a sentence. It also allows judges to delay sentencing specifically to give a young person time to attend rehab, and explicitly forbids sending a youth to jail solely because they failed to complete a treatment program.

Why does this bill exist?

Origin (Platform Promise)

Consistent with the Conservative party's focus on recovery-oriented approaches to addiction, emphasizing treatment over safe supply or decriminalization.

  • Requires police officers to consider referring a youth to an addiction treatment program (with the youth's consent) if the crime involves drugs or cannabis.

  • Allows judges to delay sentencing to give the youth time to attend an approved addiction treatment program.

  • Explicitly forbids courts from sending a youth to jail (custody) solely because they failed or refused to comply with a condition to attend rehab.

  • Adds addiction treatment programs to the list of official sanctions and supervision orders a court can impose.

  • Requires judges to consider a youth's participation in treatment when deciding on their final sentence.

Youth Offenders

(Easier)

More likely to be offered help for addiction rather than just a criminal record or probation.

Police Officers

(Neutral)

Must now formally consider rehab referrals during interactions involving drugs.

Judges

(Easier)

Gains a specific legal tool to pause sentencing while a youth seeks help.

Provincial Impact

Provincial Impact

High (Requires Provincial Action/Funding) Interaction

The bill relies on programs 'authorized by the lieutenant governor in council of a province.' Provinces must designate and fund these programs for the federal law to work.

Benefits & Pros

Tackles the root cause of crime (addiction) rather than just punishing the behavior.

Provides a safety net by ensuring that relapsing or failing rehab does not automatically result in jail time.

Gives judges more flexibility to pause legal proceedings to allow for health interventions.

Encourages police to divert youth away from the court system early on.

Beneficiaries

Youth struggling with addiction
Families of troubled youth
Addiction treatment providers

Risks & Cons

Effectiveness depends entirely on the availability of provincial treatment programs; if there are long waitlists, the bill's tools are useless.

Delaying sentencing could prolong the legal process, leaving victims or families in limbo for longer.

Youth might feel pressured to consent to treatment just to avoid harsher penalties, even if they aren't ready.

Affected Groups

Provincial health systems (increased demand without new funding)

Before & After

Currently: A 16-year-old arrested for theft to buy drugs might be sentenced to probation immediately. If they need rehab, they have to do it while on probation. Under this Bill: The judge could pause the sentencing for 6 months to let the teen go to rehab first. If they succeed, the final sentence might be much lighter.

Real World Scenario

Currently: Police catch a teenager with illegal drugs. They might charge them or give a warning. Under this Bill: The police officer is legally required to consider referring that teenager to a local addiction treatment center instead of just charging them.

Frequently Asked Questions

Votes on this bill

Vote 96

Agreed To

2nd reading of Bill C-231, An Act to amend the Youth Criminal Justice Act

Wed Apr 15 2026

Yeas: 327

Nays: 0

Total: 337

Sponsor

Luc Berthold

Member of Parliament

House of Commons

First reading

Completed on September 19, 2025

Second reading

Completed on April 15, 2026

Consideration in committee

Not yet started

Report stage

Not yet started

Third reading

Not yet started

Senate

First reading

Not yet started

Second reading

Not yet started

Third reading

Not yet started

Abuse Potential

The abuse potential is low regarding government overreach, as the bill adds protections (no jail for treatment failure). However, there is a risk of 'net-widening,' where youth who previously would have received a simple warning are now placed in intensive treatment programs they may not need, leading to deeper surveillance by the justice system. Additionally, if treatment resources are scarce, this could create a two-tier justice system where urban youth get rehab and rural youth get standard punishments.

Implementation Risk

The primary risk is a lack of treatment beds. If a judge wants to delay sentencing for rehab, but the waitlist is 8 months, the legislation cannot be effectively used.

Broad Economic Impact

Indirect

Everyday Life

Minimal impact

Admin Burden

Moderate impact

Timeline

Immediate upon Royal Assent